Somebody else made it. Who gets to cut it up?

Clipping a show you did not record is the most common rights question in this whole field, and the one most often answered by assumption.

01

Who holds the rights to a podcast episode?

Usually whoever produced it, and often not the guest. Recording, publishing and licensing rights are typically held by the show, which means a clip of a guest saying something remarkable still belongs to the show rather than to the guest or to you. Permission comes from the producer, not from the person speaking.

02

Who typically holds what

Permission comes from whoever owns the recording, which is usually the show rather than the person who said the remarkable thing.

PartyUsually holdsCan grant permission?
The show or producerThe recording and its publicationYes, usually the only one who can
The guestRights over their own likenessOnly for their part, not the recording
The hostSometimes the same as the showDepends on the arrangement
The platform hosting itNothing of substanceNo
You, having listenedNothingNo

03

How to ask for permission

A short, specific message gets answered more often than a general one. Say which episode, roughly which moments, where the clips would be posted and how the show would be credited. Offering to share the finished clips with the producers before posting shows good faith and often speeds up the reply.

Many shows have a contact address or a media page. If there is none, a direct message to the producer or the host is reasonable. Keep the reply, whatever it says, together with the clips. A written yes is the simplest protection you can have if anyone later questions the use.

If you hear nothing back after a couple of weeks, treat silence as a no rather than a yes. Following up once is reasonable; posting anyway because nobody objected in time is the assumption that causes most disputes.

04

When a show invites clipping

Some shows actively encourage fans to clip them and publish rules for doing so, such as required credits, a ban on certain edits, or a request to link the full episode. Read those rules carefully and follow them exactly. An invitation with conditions is still conditional.

Rules can change. A show that welcomed clipping last year may have signed a deal that restricts it now. If you clip a show regularly, check its policy every few months and keep a note of the version you relied on.

05

Alternatives that avoid the question

If permission is not available, you can still talk about the episode. Recording yourself summarising and reacting to the ideas, in your own words and without playing the audio, is a different kind of content from republishing the show itself, and it builds your own voice instead of borrowing someone else's.

Inviting the guest onto your own show is another route. If a guest said something remarkable elsewhere, asking them to expand on it in a conversation you record gives you clips you own outright, and often a better version of the idea.

06

Credit is not the same as permission

Writing the show's name under a clip is polite and often required, but it does not turn an unauthorised use into an authorised one. Credit tells viewers where the material came from; permission is what allows you to use it. Treat them as two separate steps and make sure you have both before you post.

Monetised accounts deserve extra care. A clip channel earning money from someone else's show is exactly the situation rights holders pay most attention to, and a single claim can affect earnings across the whole account. If income depends on clips, get the permission in writing first and keep it somewhere you can find it quickly.

07

Ask, and keep the answer

  • Find out who actually owns the recording. It is usually the show, not the speaker.
  • Ask before you build a habit on it. Many shows say yes, and many have written policies.
  • Keep a record of any permission given. A message granting it is worth saving.

Start with a recording that is yours.

Questions people ask

Do clip accounts have permission?
Some do and many do not. Widespread practice is not the same as permission, and enforcement is sporadic rather than absent.
Does crediting the show make it acceptable?
Credit is good manners and it is not a licence. Attribution does not transfer a right.
What if the show encourages clipping?
Then you have permission, and it is worth keeping a copy of where they said so.
Does fair use or fair dealing cover it?
Sometimes, and it depends heavily on your country, on how much you used and on what you added. It is a defence rather than a permission.
Is this legal advice?
No. Rights law differs substantially between countries, and anything commercial deserves proper advice.

Read next

01Anonymising someoneGuide02Quoting someoneGuide03Different on every screenGuide